Judge Doesn’t Buy Claims of Soy Wiring Lawsuits

Posted on
#electrical #lawsuit
An overhead view of a parking lot with cars neatly lined up inside parking spaces.

Owners who have been hoping to see Toyota pay for damaged to the electrical system by rodents may want to look away. A judge in California has ruled in favor of dismissing a soy-wiring lawsuit because, in the court's eyes, the problems don't violate the terms of Toyota's express warranty.

"Considering this considerable variance, it isn’t clear that Toyota could have specifically articulated any increased “risk” to any particular part of Plaintiffs’ vehicles because of the soy coated wiring." - Judge Andrew Guilford

The judge goes on (and on), eventually explaining that automakers can't be held responsible for "external actors."

"Plaintiffs are, in effect, asking the Court to stretch the implied warranty of merchantability to include some promise that no external actor will later harm Plaintiffs’ vehicles. The Court declines to extend the doctrine so far."

It's a huge blow and could set the precedent for other pending cases.

More information on carcomplaints.com

Want to Learn More?

Rodents Can't Get Enough of Toyota's Soy Wire Coating

Somewhere in the mid-2000's there was an industry-wide push by automakers to replace plastic and glass-based wiring insulation with a more eco-friendly soy-based coating. It's biodegradable, commendable, and a complete disaster for owners.

Related Toyota Generations

At least one model year in these 34 generations have a relationship to this story.

We track this because a generation is just a group of model years where very little changes from year-to-year. Chances are owners throughout these generation will want to know about this news. Click on a generation for more information.

Having car trouble?

Tell Us What's Wrong With Your Toyota

The best way to find out what's wrong with a vehicle is from the people who drive them. Not only do owner complaints help us rank vehicles by reliability, but they're often used to spark class-action lawsuits and warranty extensions. Plus, they're a great way to vent.

Add a complaint